In recent weeks, I've been forced to authenticate my pentecostal identity and justify my unorthodox theological positions. My decision to openly question the social implications of the pentecostal religious tradition has troubled my colleagues around me, and rightfully so, I suppose. I am being pushed to articulate a new (radical) vision for my faith--one than it as committed to social justice and community transformation as it is obsessed with sanctification and (w)holiness. This should not at all be a 'radical' position. Sadly, in some charismatic circles, it is. I count the steers and subtle rebukes as rites of passage--signals that compel me to dig deeper for ethotheological, Africological and ethical thought. The following is a response to questions posed by a respected adviser and trusted mentor in the academy. S/he has posed some thoughtful, intriguing and provocative questions, much like the ones I wrestle with from day to day. In this piece, I go on a tangent so as to provide insights into my theological, historical and sociopolitical worldviews. May you be challenged, encouraged, and perhaps, even grow confused by it. The journey of theological education, I've come to learn, is characterized by an unquenchable thirst for more, occasionally haunting theological dissonance, and every so often, settling clarity. Enjoy!
1. JR, don't you think Christian churches discourage critical theological inquiry in both overt and covert ways? Won't independent thought, which is neccessary for critical theological inquiry, put churches out of business?
These are challenging questions. First of all, I don’t think that religious institutions are solely, or even largely, responsible for limiting critical theological inquiry. We don’t all want it. Do we risk social solidarity for intellectual independence, inclusion for individuality? I suppose you'd ask, why should exclusion and ostracism be salient factors? Cutting against the grain, in any field, is risky. As a result, we conform to a ‘culturally acceptable’ faith or political perspective. I strongly believe that if we were all theologically hungry, and counted an independent, self-reasoned spirituality a necessity, then by popular demand, the response of the church to critical questioning would change. We have to remember that the church is simply a grouping of like-minded people guided by Divinity. It was created by and for people; it can be—and has been—changed by people. I sincerely believe that if provocative reasoning becomes a grave need, I am confident that the church will accommodate it.
I also believe that the church won’t ever go out of business. When radical thought becomes popular it leads to structural changes. And, oh, such thought can be critical, too. Consider this one example from church history: the protestant reformation. Martin Luther diversified the church because he disagreed with the rulings of the Catholic Church. Consider how many new denominations have been born after 'the great breaking away'. I still think this same revolutionary energy can consume the church. Everyone will not ‘break away’, of course; some are satisfied with a pre-packaged, ‘tried-and-‘true’’ theology. Those who want more will pursue it actively and passionately. We must also remember that critical theological inquiry, or anything critical for that matter, is a privilege—one that remains the preserve of educated elite. We fall in this category; and based on the UN’s Millenium goals concerning education, approximately ¾ of the world does not fall in this category with us.
2. What is prophetically peculiar about Pentecostalism?
Well, I knew someone would get back to me on this. The power of the Holy Spirit to use people as mouth-pieces for God is what’s peculiar and appealing about Pentecostalism. The ability to bring a fresh and timely word from God is simply remarkable. I don’t know if this ‘forth-telling’ prophetic element exists in Islam, Buddhism, Hinduism, etc. Of course, you have to count messaging from ancestors (which would include African Indigenous Religions, and sections of Hinduism.) But, speaking directly from God in these days and times, is not very popular, in my own view.
3. Isn’t Pentecostalism essentially a fundamentalist movement?
I really wouldn’t say it is. Of course, there are fundamentalist variants (mainly independent churches), but there are also inclusive, flexible branches of the movement. What really intrigues me about Pentecostalism is its trans/multi-dimensional nature. Pentecostalism exists in the Catholic, Anglican, Presbyterian, Lutheran, Apostolic, Evangelical and non-denominational churches. It is indeed true that most of the independent churches are fundamentalist, but this is not totally indicative of the religious-social movement.
4. How do you reconcile your religious identity with your views?
All my life, I was raised in independent Pentecostal churches. I was exposed to the Jesus-is-the-only-way mantra and I accept it wholeheartedly. Now, I am in a stage of questioning all this. While I do believe that Jesus is best for me, I have grown to appreciate other faith traditions, too. I believe, however, that there is something incredibly profound about the Pentecostal experience. I am coming to the realization that I am an ‘other’ Pentecostal.
5. How can a middle-class congregation preach and live social justice?
I believe such a group would have to make adequate sacrifices for the improvement of the poor or marginalized. I am coming to the realization that real justice requires great sacrifices and/or risk. Middle-class Pentecostal churches are often to run the risk of giving all of their paycheck to the church so that they can be blessed or favored by God… so they can get a big ‘financial breakthrough’ in the future. They are seldom, if ever, willing to make similar sacrifices for the improvement of humanity. I would love to see most, if not all, middle-class churches with a community development agency attached to their organization, an office through which they are actively and consistently working to address poverty, health care, climate change, etc. I don’t believe this enough, but if done right and with much diligence, it will require great sacrifice. At the very least, such efforts would bring Pentecostal churches on a better footing than it is on at this point.
So, dear friends, what are your views on these and related questions? I'd love to hear what you think!
Regards,
jr






